I attended both days of this weekend's rain-delayed Texas race, and I was one of the last to leave the track on Sunday. I have so many thoughts about what took place, I don't even know where to start. I found myself very reflective today given the events of the weekend--not just at this track, but across the country.
The
three stars of the weekend were, in no particular order, Dallara, the SAFER barrier, and the Holmatro safety team. These three things combined to likely save Josef Newgarden's life. When Newgarden and Conor Daly's crash happened, I was watching some cars in Turn 1. Truthfully, the race was pretty exciting up to that point, with lots of side-by-side action, passing, and obvious tire fall-off. I marveled at the skill displayed by the drivers to control their cars as they raced neck-and-neck with their fellow competitors at over 200 mph. In particular, Ryan Hunter-Reay, Daly, and Tony Kanaan caught my attention because they were able to pass a number of cars.
Then, on lap 43, my boyfriend frantically tapped me on the arm to call my attention to the crash. He saw it all unfold. At first all I saw was Daly, though I didn't pinpoint that it was his car right away. I thought, well that looks bad but not terrible. Then I noticed a car sliding toward our section on its side. I knew right away it was Newgarden (that bright green was unmistakable even in daylight) and when I saw the shape his car was in as it came to a stop right in front of us, I gasped and covered my mouth with my hand. I feared the worst. I thought, NO! Not Josef, please! He is one of the most likable, charismatic personalities in IndyCar and we need him. I noticed him moving around a little but I still wasn't able to relax. Every time an accident like this happens, I get this knot in my stomach that won't go away. I didn't see the accident in real time but I knew it was bad.
I watched with bated breath as the Holmatro safety crew attended to Newgarden. They blocked my view of the cockpit so I had no idea if he was alive, hurt, or if this was another James Hinchcliffe-at-Indy-type of accident where they'd need to be extra careful in extracting him from the car. Eventually I saw him stand but he almost immediately collapsed. This scared me because I thought it might be due to a head injury. I later learned from watching the replay of the race that he was just in immense pain as the safety team touched his shoulders. The ambulance pulled up and Newgarden was taken off on a stretcher, where he thankfully waved to the crowd. Yet I still didn't feel calm until official word on his status was given.
The replays showed that Daly clearly made a rookie mistake, as he admitted. On old tires, he seemed unable to fully manage them and spun out of control directly in the path of Newgarden. Newgarden's car flipped and went cockpit-first into the SAFER barrier where miraculously it managed to miss his helmet. Thank God it was not worse, and Newgarden "only" suffered a broken clavicle and right hand/wrist injuries. He will be out for awhile but at least he is still with us. Thank goodness for modern technology and safety improvements in these cars and at these tracks.
The parade of caution laps continued as crews worked to repair the broken SAFER barrier and clean up debris. I had heard rain was possible so I understood they were trying to get the race halfway completed to be official, though I still think they should have red flagged it. Sure enough, raindrops began to fall on lap 72 and the race was halted. Shortly thereafter, as we all congregated on the concourse, we experienced another downpour similar to Saturday. I knew right away there was no chance the race would be completed Sunday, but I hung around to see when it would be rescheduled.
During the second downpour, as we were one of only about 20 fans still remaining, a gentleman in a Texas Motor Speedway shirt and a hat that read "IRL Supervisor" came up to us. He asked us, "So what have
you heard?" Um, what? He must have thought we were official race personnel since we were wearing race shirts, though I guess the cooler full of refreshments didn't tip him off that we were just fans. We told him that an official announcement was to be made at 5pm CST--which I learned from Twitter. He didn't know that, nor did he know that several drivers needed to catch a flight to LeMans for another race. And he's an IRL supervisor? So here's a guy in official TMS attire who had no idea what was going on. When Graham Rahal told the TV audience that we should be given regular updates, he was right. Not only were fans not given regular updates, apparently neither were the workers.
I was not one of the upset, outraged fans who demanded that the race be held despite treacherous conditions, though there were quite a few of those. As Newgarden's crash demonstrated, we need to take safety seriously. You do not want cars hitting a puddle or wet spot and hitting the wall at over 200 mph. But I got all of my updates from social media. I knew they were trying to dry the track and that it was taking awhile due to the humidity, but I don't think the majority of the fans in attendance were aware of this fact. And of course all the armchair critics come out and say IndyCar should have run the race, or it should have been rescheduled to Monday, blah blah blah. Rahal had a valid point, and many of these criticisms could have been avoided with specific updates. Unfortunately this turned into a defensive grudge match between him and Eddie Gossage, who later appeared on Big Hoss TV to say he had no idea the race was going green or what was happening with the track drying. I don't know who to believe here. I do know that if you're the track president, you should know what is happening at your track. And you should shoulder some of the responsibility for that. Eddie does a lot of good things for the fans and for IndyCar, but I feel he also throws them under the bus more than he should, which seems unprofessional. Case in point: his claim that drivers like "old asphalt" so that's why TMS hasn't been repaved, or his comment that the extra piece of the logo sticking out on the SAFER barrier was just foam and posed no risk whatsoever. Kudos to the fans who replied, "tell that to the Columbia space shuttle astronauts," who perished because a piece of foam hit the shuttle.
Sadly, this will leave a black eye on IndyCar--and probably TMS too, though neither party had any control over the weather. Some fans blame TMS for not communicating with fans enough, for not offering a viable solution (like a refund), and for not having a good enough drainage system. Some fans blame IndyCar because they think IndyCar and IndyCar alone made the decision not to race on Saturday. They also blamed IndyCar for not having Air Titans, even though Gossage and others said with the humidity they would not have helped. (Admittedly, I had no idea what a "weeper" was until this weekend, so at least I learned something new!) While it was great that Newgarden, Hinchcliffe, Hunter-Reay, Alexander Rossi, Carlos Munoz and others went into the stands late Saturday to take selfies and sign autographs with fans, this was merely a clever PR move. I believe everyone knew at that point that the race would be called, and this was IndyCar's last-ditch effort to save face and show how fan-friendly and approachable their drivers are. Not a bad move, and I don't disagree that the drivers are awesome, but it was still a publicity stunt. (By the way, it was quite noticeable that no one from Team Penske or Ganassi went into the stands.)
The bottom line is that no matter what decision TMS and IndyCar made, it would not please everyone. More rain was forecast for Monday, and the attendance would have been abysmal. I wouldn't even have been able to attend, unless it was a night race. The teams have a pre-scheduled test at Road America on Wednesday. Next weekend Mikhail Aleshin, Sebastien Bourdais, and Scott Dixon were all scheduled to race the 24 Hours of LeMans. So what do you do? As a communications teacher this dilemma fascinated me. I think the decision to finish the race in August was the most amenable solution. Yes, some say we should restart the race from the beginning but really that would not be fair. Perhaps the race should be extended by a few laps, but we can pick up where we left off. This still will completely change the complexion of the race and give us an unpredictable finish, especially since it will be run at night again. It will be hot as hell in August but I'll be there. And I hope we don't see another incident like we saw Sunday.